Only today picked up a copy of Mojo and not had time to read the entire piece yet, but I glanced at the closing words, (always a good way to get a feel for the whole article,) and read John Leckie's comment that 'all Bill needs is an editor.'
Well, as much as I love John, I'll respectfully take issue with that comment, and for the following reasons: It implies that some kind of 'quality control' is needed, that some of the work is not as good as it could be. But, who is to say what is good and what isn't? What one editor might erase a different editor might keep. What one editor might think 'sub standard' another editor might deem essential and perfect. It just comes down to personal taste and musical bias, there are no absolutes in art.
If an editor favours classic rock, he may not be particularly disposed towards jazz or ambient or avant music and would therefore edit in favour of the former. It''s entirely subjective. and avoids generalisations. I can understand that, if you're chasing commercial success, and an editor thinks he knows what formulas might help achieve such results, he will probably edit out anything that negates a potential success. That's what many producers are hired to do, to make hits, to aim at mainstream success, that's how they earn their money after all. But an artist doesn''t consider such things, he is dedicated to following the muse and damn the torpedoes.He has to do what he has to do.
Editors are valuable for magazines and tv documentaries and so on, where numerous contributers are involved in producing the final product, (though they don't always get it right.) But a true artist and an editor are polar opposites. It becomes an imposition, a vendetta, a negation of vison and mission. An artist needs the opposite: the freedom to express whatever he wants, whenever he wants. You don't have to like it, or agree with it, but it has the right to be what it is. It's unbounded, boundless, free...
By the way, don't think for one minute that the fact that I'm a prolific musician means that any of this music comes easy to me. It's an absolute joy to create it, and I love the process, but its creation requires intensely hard work, deep thought and great and loving care. 😉